Book Review: The Short and Tragic Life of Robert Peace by Jeff Hobbs

Title: The Short and Tragic Life of Robert Peace: A Brilliant Young Man Who Left Newark for the Ivy League
Author: Jeff Hobbs
Enjoyment Rating: *****
Source: Kindle
Content Alert: Drug use and violence

Robert Peace was born in East Orange, New Jersey to a single mother who made minimum wage as a kitchen worker. His father was a drug dealer who went to prison for killing two women when Rob was a young boy. He started dealing himself when he was still a teenager. If this was all you knew about Rob Peace, you probably wouldn't be surprised to learn that Peace died in a drug-related shooting when he was 30. But Rob Peace also had a father who read with him and worked on homework every night they were together. He had a mother who made enormous sacrifices to send him to private school. He was a swimmer, a water polo player, and a student leader. He was enough of a standout at his high school that a wealthy benefactor paid for his education at Yale. He took on one of the toughest majors (Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry), and graduated from Yale having achieved some of the school's highest honors. And yet, that terrible death awaited him.

The Short and Tragic Life of Robert Peace is one of the best books I read in 2014. It was definitely my favorite nonfiction read. It reminded me a lot of The Secret Life of Henrietta Lacks, probably mostly in the way that the authors initially seem quite detached from the story, but it becomes clear that they have a personal stake in the game as the narrative unfolds (Jeff Hobbs and Rob Peace were roommates at Yale). Hobbs does a great job looking at Rob and the other people in his life, and trying to piece together why someone who overcame so many obstacles and had so much potential eventually lost his footing. Hobbs asserts that Peace's life was not a cliche, and reading the book reveals the complexity of his story. The book is definitely worth reading, and Rob Peace is a person I won't soon forget.

Book Review: Before I Fall by Lauren Oliver

Title: Before I Fall
Author: Lauren Oliver
Enjoyment Rating: ****
Source: Kindle
Content Alert: Swearing, lots of underage drinking, violence, suicide, talking about sex

It's February 12, the last day of Samantha Kingston's life. The first time Samantha lives through February 12th, she self-involved and cruel at times, reveling in her popularity and her circle of friends, and when she and her three best friends speed off, drunk, in an ice storm, their deaths feel somehow deserved. But Samantha gets a second chance, and a third, and even a sixth and seventh, not to escape death, but to live a meaningful last day of her life.

The premise of Before I Fall isn't that unique-- it's a Groundhog Day story. Samantha has one day to make things right in the world, which is a tall order. Each time she relives the day, she gains insight into her own life, her actions, and into making peace with her existence. The book is an interesting exploration into the life of teenage girls, popularity, and into the idea that the choices you make in a single day really can make a difference.

Book Review: Where Things Come Back by John Corey Whaley

Title: Where Things Come Back
Author: John Corey Whaley
Enjoyment Rating: ***
Source: Kindle
Content Alert: sex (implied but teenage), missing children, some swearing

Cullen is having a rough summer-- his cousin recently died of a drug overdose, and the sleepy Arkansas town he lives in is caught up in a frenzy over the supposed reappearance of a woodpecker that was thought to be long-extinct. Then Cullen's brother, Gabriel disappears, and he's caught up in feelings of rage an ineptitude. Cullen's story alternates with the story of a young missionary who's losing his faith while serving in Africa. While these two stories seem like a strange juxtaposition at first, they eventually come together in a satisfying way.

I know this book got a lot of hype (it won the Printz Award in 2012), but I felt that there was more emphasis on style than on storytelling. The alternating stories seemed so jarring in the beginning, and there seemed to be little emotion surrounding the conclusion to the story (which should have elicited a lot of emotion). Cullen was a somewhat unsympathetic protagonist-- I felt bad for his predicament, but didn't always identify with his actions or see them as a result of his grief.

Book Review: Lady Emma's Campaign by Jennifer Moore

Title: Lady Emma's Campaign
Author: Jennifer Moore
Enjoyment Rating: ***
Source: Digital Copy
Content Alert: Some war-related violence and torture

Lady Emma Drake has had more than her share of marriage proposals from eligible, decent men. But, try as she might, she can't get over her love for Captain Sidney Fletcher, her brother's best friend, who thinks of her as a little sister. When Emma gets word first that Sidney is dead, and then that he may actually be a prisoner of war in Spain, she steals away onto her brother's ship to help save him, eventually ending up as a prisoner of war herself. The main action of the story takes place in Spain, as Emma and Sidney journey to safety, a journey fraught with danger.

Lady Emma's Campaign is an exciting novel, with lots of action. There were parts of the story I enjoyed a lot (the beginning, in particular). However, the campaign itself dragged a bit, and I was eager for the couple to return to safety and to find a way to live happily ever after.

Book Review: Mountains Between Us by Jenny Proctor

Title: Mountains Between Us
Author: Jenny Proctor
Enjoyment Rating: ***
Source: Digital Copy
Content Alert: a clean read, but the subject matter deals with troubled teens and substance abuse

When Eliza leaves Nashville for Rockbridge Academy, in the Blue Ridge mountains, she knows that she's trading troubled adults (her sister and mother) for troubled teens (the students she will be counseling). What she doesn't figure is that love may also come her way. However, she's surprised to find that two men are vying over her, one of whom is a Mormon like Eliza, and the other one who is interested in becoming one.

Mountains Between Us is Jenny Proctor's second book that centers on the Rose Creek community (The House at Rose Creek was a finalist in the general category in 2013), and the protagonists of that novel reappear as minor characters in this story. I think this is the better executed of the two books, and I found myself engrossed in Eliza's dilemmas with her sister, her students, and her future.

Book Review: Victoria's Promise by Julie Wright

Title: Victoria's Promise (The Newport Ladies Book Club)
Author: Julie Wright
Enjoyment Rating:
Source: Digital Copy
Content Alert: a clean read

While Tori works long hours as an Assistant Director for Vows (a Bachelor-type reality show), her real passion is screenwriting. Other than those two things (and her montly book club meetings), she doesn't have much time in her life for anything else, including love. Then Tori meets Chris, who seems to be the perfect man for her. The catch? Thirty other women are vying for his love, and falling in love with him would put her own career in jeopardy. So which will she choose? Love or work?

I've probably read about half a dozen of the books in The Newport Ladies Book Club series now, and I think this one was my favorite. I'm finally seeing all of the stories start to intersect more clearly, and I think that's working well. I also really liked Tori as a character, and identified with her dilemma. I wish there had been more of Chris in the story-- she spends so much time avoiding him that it seems that she's more in love with the idea of him than actually being in love with him. That said, I really loved the surprising way the story came together in the end. This is definitely a fun read.

Book Review: Food: A Love Story by James Gaffigan

Title: Food: A Love Story
Author: James Gaffigan
Enjoyment Rating: ***
Source: Audible
Content Alert: pretty clean, unless gluttony offends you

Premise: Jim Gaffigan likes food. He likes exactly the kind of food you think he would like-- hamburgers, sausages, steak-- guy food. In this book, he says funny things about food.

I like Jim Gaffigan. I think his short YouTube clips are hilarious. I have enjoyed myself while watching his hour-long comedy specials. I would even consider going to see Jim Gaffigan live. But seven hours worth of Jim Gaffigan is entirely too much Jim Gaffigan. I thought this was a perfect book to listen to rather than read, so I could hear Gaffigan telling his stories, but in retrospect, I think it would have been better to read. You see, there's nothing new in this story. I didn't learn anything new about food in this story. I didn't learn much about Jim Gaffigan in this story. Instead, I learned basically what I already knew, that he's a midwestern boy living in NYC with a whole bunch of kids, who eats bad food and is a little fat. I think this book would appeal to hard-core Gaffigan fans, or to other people who are proud of the fact that they are not food snobs.

Book Review: Gilead by Marilynne Robinson

Title: Gilead
Author: Marilynne Robinson
Enjoyment Rating: ****
Source: Audible
Content Alert: a clean read

At seventy-seven, the Reverend John Ames knows his heart won't hold out much longer. For most of his life, he led a quiet, solitary life as a Congregationalist minister in Gilead, Iowa. But when he was in his late sixties, grace entered his life in the form of Lila, and together they had a son. And now, Ames knows that he won't live to see that son grow up. Gilead is an extended letter to that boy, a story that goes back to John Ames's own boyhood, with his Civil War-era grandfather (an abolitionist and a pastor) as well as hopes for the boy's future. The story also deals extensively with ne'er do-well John Ames Boughton (the central character of Home, the second book in the Gilead series, and the son of Reverend Ames's best friend, Reverend Boughton).

Gilead is a book I always felt guilty for not reading. After attempting Housekeeping, I didn't think I liked Marilynne Robinson's writing, and never picked up Gilead, even though many of my friends said it was their favorite novel ever. After having my mind blown by Lila a few months ago, I decided to go back and read Gilead. It is a gem of a book, John Ames is a good man with very human struggles, and he looks at those struggles (mostly) honestly. The beginning is a bit of a slog, and I would say it would be even more difficult to settle into the rhythms and cadences of John Ames's speech if I hadn't recently read Lila, and probably even more if I hadn't listened to an audio version of the book. This isn't one to speed read. It's a book with a lot of grace and wonderful ideas about parental love. It made me wonder if I don't cherish my children enough because I take my time with them for granted. I still think Lila is a superior book, but I finally do understand what all of the fuss is about with Gilead.

Book Review: I'll Give You The Sun by Jandy Nelson

Title: I'll Give You the Sun
Author: Jandy Nelson
Enjoyment Rating: *****
Source: Audible
Content Alert: swearing, sex, death of a parent

At thirteen, Noah sees the world through his artwork. Nearly everything important to him shows up in his sketchbook, and his mother, an art history professor seems to truly understand and nurture his gift. His twin, Jude, is the quintessential California surfer girl, a Daddy's girl. Despite the fact that Jude seems to run a little wild, and the two suffer from jealousies, misunderstandings, and crushes on the same boy, they're also incredibly close. When tragedy tears their family apart, their roles in the family seem to reverse, and the book examines two teens in crisis, and how they work their way back toward wholeness.

I'll Give You the Sun is a beautiful book. It's hard to write about without giving too much away, but when we encounter Jude and Noah as sixteen-year-olds, both are carrying incredible guilt for things they've done. While a less adept writer might turn the book sentimental or sermonize about the choices they make, Jandy Nelson tells a story where the twins find a sense of wholeness and learn to embrace the things they love, after a time when neither one feels worthy of love. In the same sort of sobfest vein as The Fault in Our Stars (but even better in a way, because I loved the sibling story), this is a book where love, family, and forgiveness are at the very center of the narrative. It's pretty realistic in its portrayal of struggling teenagers, so it might not be a great choice for more sensitive readers.

Book Review: The Lost Book of Mormon by Avi Steinberg

Title: The Lost Book of Mormon: A Journey Through the Mythic Lands of Nephi, Zarahemla, and Kansas City, Missouri
Author: Avi Steinberg
Enjoyment Rating: ***
Source: Kindle
Content Alert: Nothing I recall

I love the premise of The Lost Book of Mormon: Avi Steinberg was feeling stuck in his life-- living in Jerusalem, struggling in his marriage, trying to finish a novel, he became fascinated with The Book of Mormon, and decided to track the trajectory of the story, traveling from Jerusalem to Mexico, to upstate New York and Kansas City. The book occupies an interesting rhetorical situation, since Steinberg is not a Mormon. In fact, he believes that Joseph Smith is just another author trying to make it big with his first book. This might be seen by many Mormons as criticism or heresy, but it actually allows Steinberg, as an enthusiastic outsider, to make some observations about Mormon culture and the Book of Mormon that neither a believing member nor someone who wants to disprove Smith's claims could make.

And while I was attracted by the premise of the book, I wasn't as entranced by the execution. I've read a lot of immersion/stunt journalism projects (AJ Jacobs, Gretchen Rubin, Michael Pollan), and this is one of the least successful of these types of books. Steinberg starts in Jerusalem, where Nephi and Lehi may have walked (which was interesting), and then goes on a Mormon tour of ancient ruins in Mexico and Guatemala, where the story was much less about the Book of Mormon than it was about the fellow Mormons on the bus. His experience getting kicked out of the Hill Cumorah Pageant was interesting, but not necessarily insightful to the project. All in all, I enjoyed the idea of the book more than the book itself.